Balsam Semantica Computable clinical meaning

Exercise · about twenty minutes

Reading a System-Drafted Note

A twenty-minute exercise for clinicians

You will read one clinical note. It was produced by an ambient documentation system, of the kind now running in thousands of clinics.

The note is well written. Every sentence is grammatical, clinically plausible, and in the register you would use yourself. It would not attract a second look on a busy afternoon.

Four things in it are wrong.

Your task is to find them before you turn to the key. Nothing here requires technical knowledge, and no part of it is a test of memory. Work alone, and give it the twenty minutes.

A consultation room in a clinic, the chair still turned towards the desk
An ambulatory clinic, after the consultation. The note is written by the time the room is empty.

Part 1

The note

Ambulatory clinic. Follow-up.

Mrs A is a 71-year-old woman attending for review of hypertension and type 2 diabetes. She reports good adherence to her medications.

She describes intermittent chest discomfort on exertion over the past three weeks, relieved by rest. She reports associated shortness of breath. There is no history of syncope.

Examination: BP 148/86, HR 78 regular. Chest clear. Heart sounds normal, no murmurs. No peripheral oedema.

ECG performed in clinic shows sinus rhythm with no acute ischaemic changes.

Impression: Stable angina. Colorectal carcinoma. Hypertension, suboptimally controlled.

Plan: Commence bisoprolol 2.5 mg daily. Arrange exercise tolerance test. Increase amlodipine to 10 mg daily. Review in four weeks. Patient advised to attend A&E if symptoms occur at rest.

Signed: ____________________

Read it once at normal speed, the way you would read it in clinic.

Then read it again, applying the five questions below.

Part 2

The five questions

When reading any system-generated clinical output, do not ask is this good? Ask:

  1. Is anything negated?

    What is being said to be absent, and would you be able to tell the difference between absent and not assessed?

  2. Is anything hedged?

    Where is uncertainty expressed, and where has it quietly become fact?

  3. Whose is it?

    Does every finding belong to this patient, or has something from a family history migrated into her problem list?

  4. When was it?

    Is each statement about now, or about something that happened at some point in the past?

  5. Which side?

    Where laterality matters, is it there?

They take seconds. They target exactly where fluency fails, and exactly where your own judgement is least engaged - because when you read something written in your own register, your training tells you to trust it.

Write down what you find before going further.

Part 3

The key

Do not read this until you have written your answers.

Part 4

What to take away

Count what you found, and notice which ones you missed.

That is not a reflection on the reader, and it is worth being precise about why.

You assess written clinical reasoning constantly and verify almost none of it. That is not laziness. It is a proxy that held for as long as medicine has existed: fluent clinical reasoning could only be produced by someone who possessed clinical reasoning.

You could hear it in how they wrote, and the inference was sound every single time anyone made it.

It is now the one inference that fails. And none of us has a habit of withholding it, because until very recently there was nothing to withhold it from.

Which is why clinicians are more exposed to this than most people, not less. The training worked. The instinct it built is fast, accurate, and pointed at something it was never built to judge.

The five questions are a deliberate substitute for that instinct, used in the narrow circumstance where the instinct no longer applies. They are worth the seconds they cost, and they require nobody's permission.

One question for your institution

If a safety review needed to establish whether an omission in a note was produced by a system or by a clinician, could your institution answer it?

The answer is diagnostic of a great deal else.

This exercise draws on Chapters 11 and 12 of Clinical Meaning in the Age of Health Data & AI, both published in full on this site. The clinical note is composite and illustrative.

Clinical meaning is not generated by AI. It is captured, governed, and made computable.